Filmmakers Amanda McBaine and Jesse Moss are known for their ability to capture and explore the truth through their documentary films. Their portfolio includes The Overnighters in 2014 and Boys Statein 2020, the latter of which brilliantly depicted a mock government program for teen boys in Texas. Now, they have ventured to Missouri to delve into the world of American politics and government for high school girls.
Girls State is not just a gender-swapped version of Boys State, but rather a film that explores different themes and has different stakes. Boys State is involved in the campaigning process, making the viewer emotionally invested in those running for election. Girls State sets itself up that way. But considering this year’s documented program occurred shortly after the Roe v. Wade ruling was leaked, it adds an electric fever to the atmosphere.
Additionally during that time, Missouri held both the boys and girls programs on the same campus at the same time. The film showcases the differences in how the teens treat each other and the significant difference in funds allocated to each program (two guesses which one receives less money).
McBaine and Moss do not lean towards any particular political party in Girls State. Instead, they deeply examine all aspects of the coin. One of the most compelling journeys is that of Emily Worthmore, a teen candidate who aspires to run for POTUS in 2040. She makes it a point to meet everyone in the program and share her wisdom. Emily refrains from revealing her political party to new people for fear of losing half of them as soon as she mentions it. She believes in having honest discussions and embodies the saying, “One should fix another’s crown and not point out that they’re crooked.” It’s a moving storyline, particularly when her path takes an unexpected turn.
Another astounding aspect of the film is the level of support the girls offer each other. They are actively involved and even attend the boys’ discussions when the boys are not interested in doing the same.
Girls State offers hope for the future, but it also raises concerns about the future of democracy. McBaine and Moss turn in a fantastic piece of documented truth, and it’s worth watching with the entire family to spark an exciting conversation (hopefully) based on understanding without any heat.
Q&A
Fresh Fiction caught up with directors Amanda McBaine and Jesse Moss to discuss their headspace heading into and coming out of Girls State. Watch our video interview below and catch the film today on Apple TV+.
