November 17, 2026

Courtney Howard // Film Critic

THE HUNGER GAMES: SUNRISE ON THE REAPING 

Rated PG-13, 2 hours and 38 minutes

Directed by: Francis Lawrence

Starring: Joseph Zada, Whitney Peak, Mckenna Grace, Ralph Fiennes, Jesse Plemons, Elle Fanning, Glenn Close, Kieran Culkin, Ben Wang, Maya Hawke, Lili Taylor, Molly McCann, Iona Bell, Percy Daggs IV, Kelvin Harrison Jr., Billy Porter

24 years before Katniss Everdeen volunteered as tribute, there was Panem’s 50th Hunger Games when her mentor Haymitch Abernathy was a young man unwittingly chosen to compete in his first chilling competition to the death. Part riveting, taut conspiracy thriller, part poignant love story and part somber, deeply layered survivalist tale, director Francis Lawrence’s surprisingly effective prequel/ sequel THE HUNGER GAMES: SUNRISE ON THE REAPING tells the origin stories of how many of the characters we know from author Susan Collins’ adapted original trilogy were drawn into the dystopian world in the first place. Breathtaking, trail-blazing and thought-provoking, it’s one of the best in the franchise, paying reverential homage to what came before it while forging its own unique path.

Before becoming the heavy drinker we know him as, in his more youthful days, Haymitch Abernathy (Joseph Zada) was a sober, valued member of his coal mining community in District 12. His home is filled with love from his mom and little brother. He’s a personable guy, making friends with everyone from town – even the mean Maysilee Donner (Mckenna Grace), who works in the convenience store with her nice twin sister Merilee. He also has a gorgeous artistic girlfriend, Lenore Dove (Whitney Peak), who loves him and gifts him with an iridescent songbird and snake pendant on his birthday, which falls on reaping day.

During the sadistic televised ceremony hosted by Drusilla Sickle (Glen Close, whose caricatured look is BRAZIL meets Mar-a-Lago Face), he’s forced to enlist with Maysilee, his tween neighbor Louella McCoy (Molly McCann) and shy odds-maker Wyatt Callow (Ben Wang) to participate in the 50th anniversary of The Games. This sadistic televised ceremony is a big deal for Panem’s tyrannical President Snow (Ralph Fiennes) as he’s pitted players from perennial-champion districts against kids whose districts rarely if ever win, all to be guided by former winners like Wiress (Maya Hawke) and Mags Flanagan (Lili Taylor). Leading the events are host Caesar Flickerman (Kieran Culkin) and director Plutarch Heavensbee (Jesse Plemons). Yet there’s an underground rebellion brewing that desperately needs Haymitch’s help to break free from the machine that’s enslaved them all.

Ben Wang as Wyatt Callow, Percy Daggs IV as Ampert Latier, Joseph Zada as Haymitch Abernathy, and Mckenna Grace as Maysilee Donner in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping. Photo Credit: Courtesy of Lionsgate.

Lawrence and adapting screenwriters Billy Ray (who turned in incredibly captivating, emotionally taut work with 2012’s THE HUNGER GAMES) and Michael Lesslie (who turned in subpar work with 2023’s THE BALLAD OF SONGBIRDS AND SNAKES) do an expert level job blurring any sharply defined 1:1 comparison lines drawn between their creative, new narrative and the saga’s upcycled story outline and elements. Tween competitor Ampert Latier (Percy Daggs IV), whose presence and emotional through-line are akin to Rue’s in the 2012 film, also doubles as the son of former champion Beetee Latier (Kelvin Harrison Jr., who’s a sound-a-like for Jeffrey Wright), and is used by Snow for blackmail purposes. The deadly arena challenges the contestants face (like the electrocuting butterflies, poisoned river water, flood of lava and leech-like berries) all pull from touchstones in the previous Jennifer Lawrence-led chapters. Every character carries a specific traumatic weight. Those working for the Capitol’s oligarch – Effie, Wiress, Mags and Plutarch – are good folks working inside a corrupt system, using their skillsets to survive in a grim reality and hoping for a change to come.

Its sentiments that the smallest spark can create a fire resound on a similar key as Katniss’ journey, but feel independently resonant in our own era, as we face mass-media propaganda and technology-fueled lies disseminated by real-world tyrannical leaders and their ghoulish cabals. Haymitch initially believes change is impossible, but it proves inspirational when Lenore posits the opposite: Just because things have always been this way doesn’t mean they always will. Plus, his arc, becoming someone whose guilt is later weaponized, contains fascinating psychological stakes even before what inevitably happens with Lenore actually occurs. As a biblical retribution turns him into a Job-esque character, we feel his anguish and burden.

The film, of course, suffers from its fair share of what we’ll call Stupid Protagonist Stuff. After learning his cape’s capabilities, it’s frustrating that Haymitch’s first move isn’t always to use it as a problem solver. It makes the audience question his intelligence. It’s baffling why he cares about the survival of Louella’s replacement Lou Lou (played by Iona Bell) enough to jeopardize his own – plus it’s a missed opportunity that he doesn’t gift her a pun-worthy name like “Nu-ella.” There’s another maddening moment where he runs after the sound of a bell to help a contestant though it’s clearly a trap. From the disastrous chariot race with passengers unable to control their horses to the gummies left on the rock, audiences will spot some glaringly obvious dangers that don’t exactly serve as the tension-escalating devices the filmmakers think they’re subtly crafting. It’s also quite the questionable choice to have District 12’s stylist Magno Stift (Billy Porter, a Black gay man) depicted as late and lazy.

Kieran Culkin as Caesar Flickerman in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping. Photo Credit: Courtesy of Lionsgate

The colorful visual aesthetic brilliantly runs antithetical to the dread-soaked atmosphere and gloomy undercurrent of the narrative. The Capitol’s 70s-style interiors are covered in rich gold, browns, ambers and royal blue color schemes, from the boxy, old-school tech on the TV cameras to the over-the-top Vegas-like razzle dazzle game show set, Plutarch’s golden library and the tributes’ hospitality suite. Uli Hanisch’s production design adds class, rooting the proceedings in a familiar flair as if the hopefulness of that era of progress cloaks a sinister side. Bina Daigeler’s costume design is top notch, speaking volumes about the characters through texture, color and fabric.

Though we’ve seen many of these characters before, the new actors shade them with new hues. Zada is fantastic, helping shape the compelling, conflicted hero that Woody Harrelson portrayed previously. He gives the character depth and dimension in an electrifying performance, taking it beyond a “this is how his ringlet curls were turned straight” origin story. Clearly Close is having the time of her life, taking her ostentatious, psychotic fashionista to gloriously hammy heights. There’s no scenery she will not chew and no personality she won’t skewer. Plemons, who picks up the early iteration of Philip Seymour Hoffman’s principled creation, and Culkin, who rewinds the clock on Stanley Tucci’s effervescent parody of a game show host, are undeniable highlights. I would watch an entire movie of Elle Fanning as Effie Trinket. She takes what Elizabeth Banks did and turns it up to eleven, giving her incarnation a renewed sense of vim, vigor and vibrancy.

Given the melancholy epilogue this chapter ends on, if this is meant to be the last HUNGER GAMES film, then they finished on a high note. If not, I can only hope the next cinematic offering it inspires (perhaps that aforementioned Effie Trinket stand-alone, pretty please?) will be just as sharp as this was.

Grade: 4 out of 5

THE HUNGER GAMES: SUNRISE ON THE REAPING is in theaters on November 20.

Leave a Reply